The Bottom Line
Pros
- Strong teleplays based on ideas from well-known writers.
- Powerful, but clean, direction and production values.
- Outstanding and occasionally riveting performances by name actors.
Cons
- Intelligent writing is not always immune from preachy endings (applies mostly to "The Awakening").
- Only four of the six produced episodes will be broadcast.
Description
- "A Clean Escape" (Sam Waterston, Judy Davis): Perhaps the strongest entry, powerfully written, directed, and acted.
- "The Awakening" (Terry O'Quinn, Elisabeth Rohm): Although the ending is delivered from a soap box, it's still smart and fun.
- "Jerry Was a Man" (Anne Heche, Malcolm McDowell): I enjoyed immensely this Heinleinian exploration of what it is to be human.
- "The Discarded" (Brian Dennehy, John Hurt): Come on, how often do you get Dennehy and Hurt in a story by Harlan Ellison?
Guide Review - Masters of Science Fiction
Apart from entirely superfluous, perhaps because extremely brief (one sentence each at the top and bottom of the show), off-screen host narration by the physicist Stephen Hawking, there is nothing about these shows that was obviously done merely to pander to audiences of sci-fi fans. Each of the four screen episodes (two more were made, and hopefully will appear on the eventual DVD) has an excellent look and feel that recalls other well-crafted shows like The X-Files.
Several of the performances are outstanding. Sam Waterston and Judy Davis are ideally suited to each other as they drive their story, "A Clean Escape," toward a conclusion that's mesmerizing not only for the twist ending but for the envelope-pushing performances of both actors. In "The Awakening," Lost's Terry O'Quinn delivers another variation on his patented everyman philosopher, here to great effect; he's counterbalanced by a progressively more frantic U.S. president, evoked nicely by X-Files's William B. Davis. Malcolm McDowell is delicious as usual in the arch, Heinlein-based "Jerry Was a Man"; as for his co-star, Anne Heche: normally I find her mannered and overdone, but here those qualities are perfect for the larger-than-life character she plays, a unimaginably wealthy woman who goes to see a man about a novelty custom-crafted animal and ends up taking home a doomed android.


